Support TIME. Preserve the truth.
Arberi

Student List aims to review agreements with Kosovo, EU says Serbia must implement them

Student List

The Student List warns that it will review the constitutionality of the agreements reached in the Brussels dialogue. Pristina, meanwhile, says that normalizing relations begins with accepting reality.

"Kosovo is an independent and sovereign state and its independence is irreversible," reads the response from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Diaspora of Kosovo to Radio Free Europe (RFE/RL).

The Student List won the elections in Serbia, defeating the Serbian Progressive Party, which had been in power for 14 years.

In the part of the program dedicated to national interests, the Student List says that it will oppose Kosovo's independence and will not allow its membership in international organizations.

By accepting the Agreement on the path towards normalization of relations in 2023, Serbia pledged that it would not oppose Kosovo's membership in international organizations.

The parties also agreed on a plan for implementing the agreement. The agreement stipulates that Kosovo and Serbia will respect each other's territorial integrity and recognize each other's national symbols.

The Student List also warns that it will prosecute all "responsible representatives of the regime for all possible criminal offenses related to the conclusion and implementation of unconstitutional agreements to the detriment of Serbia."

What does the EU say?

The European Union, which is mediating the dialogue between Pristina and Belgrade, says that Serbia remains obliged to respect the commitments it made in the dialogue even after the change of power.

"The results of the parliamentary elections in Serbia do not change the basis of the EU-mediated dialogue nor the obligations undertaken by the parties," an EU spokesperson said in a statement to REL following the Student List's victory.

The EU expects Serbia to continue to engage constructively in the dialogue, to fulfil its obligations and to assist in the normalisation of relations with Kosovo.

Belgrade still does not recognize Kosovo's independence. Since the start of the dialogue in 2011, the parties have reached dozens of agreements on issues such as freedom of movement, integration of the judiciary and police, electricity, telecommunications, recognition of diplomas, and the status of the Serbian community in Kosovo.

What does Kosovo say?

Kosovo's Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Diaspora told Radio Free Europe that full normalization of relations with Serbia can only be achieved if mutual recognition is at the center of the process.

"Only on this basis can European good neighborly relations be built. We remain committed to a dialogue that helps achieve this goal and enables the region to overcome recurring tensions and move towards sustainable peace and continued cooperation," the Ministry said.

According to the Ministry, the Student List's stance towards Kosovo could deepen the divisions that the dialogue aims to overcome.

"The Student List's promise for the political renewal of Serbia sounds unconvincing when its program officially expresses the same territorial ambitions that characterized the previous government's policy towards the Republic of Kosovo. They consider our country part of Serbia, explicitly define this as a political objective and promise to block our membership in international organizations," the Ministry's response states.

Petrov says annulling agreements Serbia has implemented is almost impossible

The President of the Constitutional Court of Serbia, Vladan Petrov, said in a written response to Radio Free Europe that, according to him, it is almost impossible to restore the situation before the implementation of the agreements that Serbia reached with Kosovo.

Petrov, who stressed that he was expressing his personal opinion, said that Serbia would have a constitutional basis to unilaterally withdraw from the dialogue only if the Constitutional Court were to reverse its 2014 stance and treat the agreements as international treaties.

In 2014, the Constitutional Court of Serbia rejected a request to review the constitutionality and legality of the First Brussels Agreement. The court considered it a political agreement, without the status of an international treaty.

"But, I repeat, whatever their nature, the Republic of Serbia has fully implemented them for a long time, so the question naturally arises as to what concrete consequences such a decision could bring, even if we take it as a hypothesis," Petrov said.

After winning the elections, representatives of the Student List demanded the resignation of several institution leaders, including Petrov.

What is the purpose of reviewing agreements?

Bogolub Milosavljevic, a professor of constitutional law in Serbia, says that it is still not clear how the Student List will review the agreements reached in the dialogue with Kosovo and what it aims to achieve with this review.

"I do not believe that any step would be taken that contradicts the goals and plans of the Student List to get closer to the European Union. The review [of agreements within the framework of the dialogue for the normalization of relations with Kosovo] must have a purpose, because the previous government did all sorts of things," he told REL.

Dušan Janjić, from the Belgrade Forum for Ethnic Relations, sees the warning to review the constitutionality of the agreements as a call for partnership with the EU and for a minimum of respect. He does not expect the Student List to turn to the Constitutional Court of Serbia.

From a constitutional point of view, Janjic says that a pause in dialogue would serve Kosovo and Serbia to create the conditions for partnership and to continue the dialogue on new grounds.

"Let's not rush. Let's lay the foundations for the continuation of the dialogue," said Janjic. According to him, the Constitutional Court's 2014 decision remains in force, as no one can review it.

Artan Muhaxhiri, a political analyst from Pristina, describes the Student List's stance towards Kosovo as a "populist narrative" that conflicts with Serbia's goals of getting closer to the EU.

According to Muhaxhir, the Student List has the potential to bring about “fundamental positive changes in Serbian society.” But, he says, the List would miss this opportunity if it chooses to “enter into an irrational and pre-emptively losing battle to change history in the context of Kosovo.”

"The success of their progressive ideas for the emancipatory political and socio-cultural transformation of Serbia will depend on how realistic their approach to the most difficult and delicate processes will be. Relations with Kosovo should be among the top priorities," he told REL.

Muhaxhiri sees the presidential elections in Serbia, which should be held by the end of the year, as the only explanation for the Student List's stance towards Kosovo so far.

According to him, the dialogue cannot continue if the Student List does not change its approach towards Kosovo.