The protests in Tirana and Belgrade are similar, because they are fighting the same thing. For the first time in our region, the main battle is no longer ethnic or geopolitical – it is a civic battle between the new generation of European youth and the decadent Balkan politicians of a bygone era.
Albania and Serbia are countries with different histories, yet these days the streets of Tirana and Belgrade are remarkably similar. The protests in Tirana and Belgrade have shown that despite their vast historical differences, the citizens of both countries demand one thing in common: accountable and democratic governance.
In both countries, the recent protests have been triggered by state failure. In Serbia’s case, the state literally collapsed when part of a train station collapsed in Novi Sad, killing 16 Serbian citizens. In Albania, the state collapsed live on air, when gangs terrorized and dragged innocent citizens away in front of state institutions in Zvërnec.
And although in both countries these two initial events became symbols of protests, very quickly the protests transformed into movements for a change in the political class and the governance model. In both countries, the protests also caught fire when it was realized that their governments were making a mess of public property by camouflaging it as foreign direct investment. In both countries the protests are being led by young people in a peaceful manner and are the result of organic civic self-organization in both respective countries. Their demands are almost identical: the rule of law, political reform, transparency and accountability. Even their chants, their slogans, and their charming banners are very often similar.
The striking similarity between the protests in Albania and Serbia is no coincidence. The protests in Tirana and Belgrade are similar because they are fighting the same thing: the old political class. Thus, for the first time in our region, the main battle is no longer ethnic or geopolitical – it is a civic battle between the new generation of young Europeans against the decadent Balkan politicians of the past era. It reveals two parallel transformations that are taking place in our region. Beyond their different ethnicities, citizens are becoming increasingly similar in their progressive and democratic demands, while their political leaders are becoming increasingly similar in fighting for their democratic demands – be it Edi Rama or Aleksandar Vučić.
Thus, although Rama and Vučić could not be more different individuals, with different histories, different tastes and different aspirations, they are united in one thing – holding on to power. To hold on to this power and to fight the protesters, they have used almost identical technologies to delegitimize and undermine them.
Both Rama and Vučić have attacked the protesters as elements of foreign agencies. For Rama they were Iranians, Greeks and Serbs. For Vučić they were Westerners, Croats and Albanians. Both have used “Çaci” and “patronazists” as their party weapons to intimidate the protesters. Both have created their “Çacilands” and “Zeqilands”. Both have militarized the media close to the government to spread the government message in order to control the public narrative. Where Vučić had Pinku and Informer, Rama had Topi and the Klan. Both have tried to target specific individuals among the protesters to delegitimize and divide the protesters. Where Vučić used Natasha Kandic for an anti-Serbian narrative, Rama used Dritan Goxhaj for an anti-Albanian narrative. Likewise, both Rama and Vučić have used calibrated violence to provoke protesters and portray the protests as violent anarchists.
also What lessons should other autocrats in the region learn from Vučić's defeat?It is remarkable to see how two people as different as Rama and Vučić have developed and used the same political technologies to respond to the protesters. This allows us to conclude that there is nothing Albanian or Serbian here, nothing left or right, nothing east or west, nothing cosmopolitan or nationalist – here we are dealing with two people who refuse to relinquish power. And these similarities are not just stories about Rama or Vučić. They show that the Balkans are entering a new political phase.
For decades, the Balkans have been a theater of ethnic conflicts, borders, and geopolitical rivalries. Today, for the first time, a new division is being outlined in our region. The region is no longer divided between Albanians and Serbs, between East and West, but between citizens and their political elites. For the first time, the main battle in our region is no longer ethnic or geopolitical. It is a civic battle between a new European generation of the future and the Balkan elites of yesterday. Out of all this, a new Balkans will be born.